Review: Volume 36 - Children's Books

Review: Volume 36 - Children's Books

"Ripley's Twists" bring a fun, engaging and uniquely Ripley's approach to a whole range of topics, from the human body to space. Each title blends stunning full-colour photographs and illustrations with clear explanations and extraordinary facts that are guaranteed to inform and to entertain. In "Wild Animals" you will find: key information - everything from how much an elephant eats per day to how flies digest their food; intriguing bite-size facts - a swarm of desert locusts devours 32 million kilograms of food every 24 hours; real-life stories - like the Malaysian reticulated python who swallowed an entire sheep and then, too full to move, had to be hauled off the road by firemen; 'Big word alert' glossaries - clear and straightforward explanations of difficult words such as 'omnivore'; stunning photographs and detailed diagrams; and, a full-colour pull-out poster.

"Ripley's Twists" bring a fun, engaging and uniquely Ripley's approach to a whole range of topics, from the human body to space. In "Mighty Machines" you will find: key information - everything from how much a monster truck wheel costs to how the drivers stay safe; intriguing bite-size facts - a monster truck can jump a distance of 40 metres; real-life stories - like Bigfoot, whose giant tires were originally made in the 1950s for the US Army to use on an Arctic snow train in Alaska; 'Big word alert' glossaries - clear and straightforward explanations of difficult words; stunning photographs and detailed diagrams; and, a full-colour pull-out poster.

"Ripley's Twists" bring a fun, engaging and uniquely Ripley's approach to a whole range of topics, from the human body to space. In "Mighty Machines" you will find: key information - everything from how much a monster truck wheel costs to how the drivers stay safe; intriguing bite-size facts - a monster truck can jump a distance of 40 metres; real-life stories - like Bigfoot, whose giant tires were originally made in the 1950s for the US Army to use on an Arctic snow train in Alaska; 'Big word alert' glossaries - clear and straightforward explanations of difficult words; stunning photographs and detailed diagrams; and, a full-colour pull-out poster.

Following hot on the heels of last year's best-selling edition, "Ripley's Believe It or Not! 2010" offers a whole new feast of bizarre facts, fiends and freaks - all guaranteed to fascinate, surprise and amaze. Marvel at the ice man, who survived Everest's 'Death Zone' in just a pair of shorts; try not to scream in fright at the living zombie, covered head to toe in ghoulish tattoos; steel your stomach against the sight of cockroach and caterpillar sushi; and praise the heroic pet parrot who saved a family from their burning home. Illustrated throughout with extraordinary colour photographs, this fascinating book is a must-have for anyone intrigued by the stranger aspects of our planet and its inhabitants.


Book Review

The New York Times Book Review is available separately from the Sunday newspaper. It contains reviews of new releases, author interviews and coverage of the book world. It also has best-seller lists for fiction, nonfiction and paperbacks, among other categories.

A Book Review subscription is $4.00 (USD) per week for customers in the United States, $4.95 (USD) per week for Canadian subscribers and $5.50 (USD) per week for all other foreign addresses. A digital subscription is available on Kindle for $2.99 per month or $35.88 per year.

To purchase a New York Times Book Review subscription, please contact Customer Care .

2. How do I submit a book to be reviewed by The New York Times Book Review?

During the Covid-19 pandemic, The New York Times Book Review is operating remotely and will accept physical submissions by request only. If you wish to submit a book for review consideration, please email a PDF of the galley at least three months prior to scheduled publication to [email protected] Include the publication date and any related press materials, along with links to NetGalley or Edelweiss if applicable. Due to the volume of books we receive, we cannot respond to individual requests about our plans for coverage. Thank you.

Please email your letter to the editor to [email protected]

4. How are the best-seller lists tabulated?

Rankings reflect unit sales reported on a confidential basis by vendors offering a wide range of general interest titles published in the United States. Every week, thousands of diverse selling locations report their actual sales on hundreds of thousands of individual titles. The panel of reporting retailers is comprehensive and reflects sales in tens of thousands of stores of all sizes and demographics across the United States. You can read more about our methodology , the weekly routines of our best-seller lists department and other details of how the lists are put together.


WinterPromise Curriculum

WinterPromise (WP) has developed a surprisingly broad curriculum for preschool through high school levels over the past few years. It's a themed curriculum, similar to a unit study but with a few differences. WP predominantly uses the Charlotte Mason approach to education, but much of the learning occurs around themes as in unit studies. Along with real books, WP courses use ebooks published by WinterPromise, the occasional text or workbook from another publisher, and your choice of math programs from other publishers. WP incorporates technology such as interactive computer programs, DVDs, CDs, and website links. Like unit studies, WP incorporates lots of hands-on activities and projects. It is also a multi-level program to some extent so that you can often teach students working at more than one level from the same course.

Core Packages

Similar to Sonlight and BookShark in one way, with WP you select your core curriculum package called a “themed program,” which might be themed around either history or science. Listed below are the themed programs, a brief description when appropriate, and their grade levels. (Note: The first two programs might be used simultaneously over one or two years.)

Journeys of Imagination - an introduction to children's literature (preK)
I'm Ready to Learn - readiness for math, language, science, etc. (preK-K)
Hideaways in History (K-1)
Animals and Their Worlds - animals and science (1-4)
Children Around the World - culture and geography (2-6)
The American Story 1 - early American history (1-3)
The American Story 2 - Civil War through the 20th century (2-4)
American Crossing (4-7)
American Culture (5-8)
Adventures in the Sea & Sky - history of sea, air, and space travel that incorporates the science for each area (4-6)
Quest for the Ancient World - ancient history (4-8)
Quest for the Middle Ages - history and science themes (4-8)
Quest for the Ancient World (9-12)
Quest for the Middle Ages (9-12)
Quest for Royals & Revolution - the period of exploration and colonization (10-12)

After choosing your core theme package, you also select language arts and a science curriculum—if the themed program isn't already focused primarily upon science—from coordinating packages published by WP. They also sell Horizons Math, the Life of Fred math series, and Saxon Math, although none of the math programs are incorporated into the rest of the curriculum as essential items.

History follows chronological themes in all of the themed guides except for Journeys of Imagination, I’m Ready to Learn, Animals and Their Worlds, and Children Around the World. Timelines are used in most of the programs to help children understand the flow of history and relationships between events.

Guidebooks

The key item in each curriculum package is a guidebook. Each guidebook provides basic instruction on how to use the materials in the package, detailed daily lesson plans, a supply list, and additional lesson plans/schedules for older students who will complete some of their work independently when appropriate. Guidebook pages are three-hole punched for insertion in a binder for use for both planning and record keeping. Simply check off assignments as completed.

Guidebooks are very easy to use. They are designed to make WP a curriculum with minimal teacher preparation work. Each guidebook directs you in the use of quite a number of books and resources. You can purchase various packages—choose print or ebook versions of guides and some of the other books, and choose either basic or more comprehensive packages. Packages do not include the adventure reading books although all of the books are available from WinterPromise by special order. Required novels and biographies are easily available through the library and other sources.

As an example, The American Story 1 Guide and Exclusives Set for the early grades includes the guidebook and two WinterPromise exclusive items: A New Land (Early American stories) and Make-Your-Own American History Book (for creating timeline pages). The complete set includes 18 more history-related books that are biographies or brief topical history books written for children. There are two Bible study books, four activity resource books, and seven more books on Native Americans (the focus theme). On your own you need to obtain the ten adventure reading books that tie into the historical theme—books such as Ben and Me and Little House on the Prairie. In addition, you will need timeline creation items which WP also offers, or you can use your own. You might also want the optional Early American Trades & Crafts Kit. A few of the items are consumable, so you will need extras for additional students, but most items are non-consumable.

Activity Books and Notebooks

I mentioned WinterPromise’s Make-Your-Own American History book for The American Story 1. A similar Make-Your-Own book is included in each history-themed package. These unique publications have a variety of activity sheets for students to use for creating their own notebooks. A separate Timelines in History book consists of heavy cardstock pages, punched for a binder. Students use these pages to create their own timelines using figures sold by WP, Homeschool in the Woods, or another source. Notebook pages from Make-Your-Own books correlate with their respective courses and can be inserted between timeline pages if you so choose.

WP has started creating premiere versions of their interactive notebooks for some of their courses. I reviewed the Make-Your-Own World Travels Diary notebook for Children Around the World. This 286-page ebook is in full-color, but pages can be printed in either color or black and white for children to add to their notebooks. (A print version is available in black and white with selected color pages in the back.) Make-Your-Own World Travels Diary includes country maps to be colored and/or labeled Flags and Facts pages to complete Native Costume pages that have children add details to drawings of costumes Folks to Know pages and Things to See pages with a variety of drawing, writing, and arts-and-crafts activities Culture and Traditions pages, again with a variety of activities and Postcard pages that have illustrated postcards on which children can write (writing prompts included). Some activities are recommended for older or younger students and some for all students.

Bible study is included in all themed programs, usually, but not always, coordinating with the program theme. Resources and perspective are Protestant. The Christian (Protestant) worldview carries through the entire WP curriculum even though some of the books used are secular. The publisher notes in the lesson plans when there might be potential problems for Christians such as evolutionary assumptions. Children Around the World is a good example of how the Christian worldview is incorporated. It has wonderful sections that help children understand the poverty and danger in which many children live, then it encourages children to pray for other countries and cultures.

Language Arts

WP language arts programs are comprehensive, covering phonics, readings, vocabulary, spelling, handwriting, grammar, composition, and communication, each at the appropriate levels. These programs include some workbooks like Explode the Code, SpellWell, Wordly Wise, and Easy Grammar. But they also include activity books and sets of real books to be used as readers. Reader packages are selected to coordinate with the themed programs. Language arts programs are available for preK through high school, but only three programs for high school level are available at this time. Guidebooks for language arts have the same type of four-day lesson plan schedules that make it easy to use and coordinate all of the resources. Language arts programs for beginning readers require quite a bit of one-on-one instruction as you would expect, but once children are independent readers, the language arts programs require minimal instruction.

Science

The nine WP science programs are intended to supplement the core programs that already have varying amounts of science included. Science program titles are followed by a brief description and the appropriate grade levels.
The World Around Me - introduces children to basic science topics such as nature, water, light, color, and the night sky (K-2)
Hoot & Chirp, Buzz & Bite - a study of birds, plants, and bugs (1-4)
Dinosaur Days - teaches about dinosaurs from a creationist perspective (2-6)
Rock Around the Earth - geology and earth science (3-6)
Equine Science - specializes in the study of horses (3-7)
Human Body and Forensics 4/6 - body systems and forensic science (4-6)
Jiggle, Jostle & Jolt - introduces energy, electricity, magnetism, and heat (4-7)
Slimy, Grimy and Scummy No More - conservation science (7-9)
Human Body and Forensics Jr/Sr - advanced version of this course (7-12)

These programs should take only two to five hours per week to complete. All science programs include guidebooks plus a number of other books, always including some with hands-on activities.

By now, you might be envisioning quite a stack of books for each year, and that is certainly an accurate picture of this curriculum—lots of books and lots of reading to do. But the selected books, especially for younger levels, are often colorful and appealing, and most are real books rather than texts or workbooks. Many of these books are ones you would love to have in your family library.

Scheduling and Accountability

WP is designed for a 36-week school year. Schedules are set up for four days per week. The fifth day might be used for field trips, extended activities, reading, or tackling some of the ideas in the curriculum that you don't have time for the rest of the week. It doesn't seem likely that families could actually get through all of the read-aloud books and activities that come in each package, so you will sometimes have to be selective. While there is lot of reading since this is a literature-based program, WP also incorporates plenty of hands-on and active learning activities. More hands-on and arts-and-crafts type activities are included for younger students while older students are given more research and writing projects. Older students still have plenty of hands-on work such as experiments, active investigations, and practical applications. WP has made it a bit easier to select among the numerous activities by coding them as to how easy or difficult they are and how much prep time is needed.

While preparation time is minimal aside from some of the more challenging projects, parents/teachers spend a great deal of time actually using the program with their children, especially at younger levels. Most of the books for younger students are read alouds, while only a few are read alouds at upper levels. In keeping with Charlotte Mason methods, children do narrations, create notebooks, and participate in activities with varying amounts of parental assistance.

You might have also noticed that there's no mention of tests and answer keys. While answer keys come with the SpellWell books used in the language arts programs and are optional for a few other workbooks, there are no tests and answer keys for the core programs. Instead, children write, narrate, and create notebooks—demonstrating their knowledge through their activities. Parents work closely with their children and can easily spot when a child does or does not understand a concept. Nevertheless, WP guides suggest using games (directions included) if you want to quiz children on retention of information as well as other methods of evaluation.

Summary

WP has gradually been writing and producing many of their own books. These coordinate much better with the themed guides than trying to use books from other publishers. They also help create a consistent Christian worldview. In addition, since most of the WP books are published as either print or ebooks, the ebook versions present an opportunity to lower the cost of your curriculum.

The curriculum intentionally does not align with state or Common Core standards. Like most unit studies, topics are studied fewer times but at greater depth than occurs in standard textbooks. Ultimately, children are likely to cover all of the required topics, but they are also likely to retain more since learning methods are much more appealing.

The publisher's website has explanations, free sample pages, a discussion board and other information that will help you better understand the curriculum before purchasing.

Pricing Information

When prices appear, please keep in mind that they are subject to change. Click on links where available to verify price accuracy.

Examples of pricing:
Children Around the World: basic print package (WP exclusives and core books) - $219 or basic ebook package (digital versions of WP exclusives and cores books) - $119
The World Around Me science program - $139
Third Grade Language Arts program (ebooks and print set) $109
Check the WinterPromise website for complete pricing information.


Privacy Statement: If you sign-up for our email newsletter we will not share your email address with any other company nor use it ourselves for anything other than mailing you our newsletter (ever).

Volume 15, Issue 2. Book Reviews, Grades PreK through 10th. Volume 15, Issue 1. Deserts through Children's Books. Volume 14, Issue 7. Book Reviews. Volume 14, Issue 6. Featured Book Article on Where the Wild Things Are with activities, related books and links. Author Study of Maurice Sendak. Volume 14, Issue 5. History through Time-Travel Fantasies. Volume 14, Issue 4. Book Reviews. Volume 14, Issue 3. Picture Books in the Math Curriculum. Volume 14, Issue 2. Reviews of New Children's Books. Volume 14, Issue 1. Celebrating the 200th birthdays of Abraham Lincoln and Charles Darwin. Volume 13, Issue 3. Reviews of nonfiction books and recommended links. Volume 13, Issue 1. Reviews of books and recommended links. Volume 12, Issue 2. My Side of the Mountain by Jean Craighead George. Volume 12, Issue 1. Nory Ryan's Song by Patricia Reilly Giff. Volume 11, Issue 1. Reviews of new book releases. Volume 10, Issue 3. Featured Book: The Breaker Boys by Pat Hughes. Volume 10, Issue 2. Featured Book: Kira-Kira by Cynthia Kadohata. Volume 10, Issue 1. Featured Book: Olive's Ocean by Kevin Henkes. Volume 9, Issue 8. Featured Subject: The Holocaust. Volume 9, Issue 7. Featured Subject: Time of the Pilgrims: 1600-1700. Volume 9, Issue 6. Featured Book: Charlotte's Web by E. B. White. Volume 9, Issue 5. Featured Book: Look to the North by Jean Craighead George. Volume 9, Issue 4. Featured Book: Miss Bridie Chose a Shovel. Volume 9, Issue 3. Featured Author: Susan Goodman. Volume 9, Issue 2. Featured Book: Attaboy, Sam! by Lois Lowry. Volume 9, Issue 1. Featured Book: The Man Who Walked Between the Towers by Mordicai Gerstein. Volume 8, Issue 9. Featured Subject: Weather.

Don't miss a thing! Sign up for our Free Newsletter.
Sign Up!

Free Teacher's Guides for Novels, Picture Books and Nonfiction. For Preschool through Ninth Grade.

In Times Past
an eBook
by Carol Hurst and Rebecca Otis

Integrating US History with Literature in Grades 3-8.

Enliven your US History curriculum!

Teach US History using great kids books.


ws-na.amazon-adsystem.com Rocks in His Head.


Example Lesson from Story of the World

Read the chapter aloud - have children take notes (more on that in a minute!), do narration questions and mapwork suggested in the guide.

We might also consult the Kingfisher History Encyclopedia to see what it has to say about the events presented, too.

My son (who is 8 and in second grade) builds LEGO creations to along with our chapter, colors a coloring sheet from the activity guide, or draws while listening to the chapter. I require my daughter to take more extensive notes since she is middle grades now.

Throughout the course of the week we had read-aloud to go with our chapter. This particular week it was Blood on The River, an excellent living book about a page working for Captain John Smith.

I also know that Handel was living at this same time in Europe, so we completed the Handel lesson from SQUILT Volume 1.

We also had a book of Isaac Newton activities and chose a couple that interested the kids.

One night we sat as a family and watched Nightmare in Jamestown on Netflix.

We read passages from the King James Version of the Bible.

You get the idea. Anything related to this period of time we were researching and enjoying. Use your imagination and let your children be your guide, too.

Yes, it took some legwork on my part. But, it's a lifestyle of learning that I believe is worth it.

The activity guide does a lot of the research for you, though, and after a while I came to enjoy the research. I am learned so much about history.


Review: Volume 36 - Children's Books - History

Martha Bailey (email: baileym@queensu.ca), Professor of Law, Queen’s University, Canada, holds a doctorate in law from Oxford University. She has published extensively on current and historical aspects of family and marriage law.

Volume 36, No. 1 &mdash Winter 2015

M ARRIAGE IS THE CENTRAL THEME AND CONCLUSION of Jane Austen’s novels. But marriage in Regency England was a very different institution from what it is here and now, in large part because of changes in the law relating to marriage. Knowledge of the marriage law of Austen’s world gives a deeper understanding of her books. More importantly, the books give us a richer appreciation of how marriage laws structured the lives of men and women. Austen conveys the lived reality of those subject to early nineteenth-century laws relating to the economic arrangements of marriage, pre-marital sex, the marriage of relatives, clandestine and underage marriage, divorce, and adulterine bastardy.

The economics of marriage

The economics of marriage among the nobility and the gentry are not only much discussed in the books but also form the crucial context of the marriage plot. Many Austen characters are challenged by inadequate fortunes, and marriage is, for some, a solution to their financial difficulties. Within the normative order of the novels, marriage for money alone is wrong, but marriage without a fortune on at least one side is imprudent.

The men who figure in Austen’s novels are certainly more likely than the women to have wealth and income. To some extent, the relative poverty of women was the result of legal rules favoring men, in particular eldest sons. If the owner of a family estate—the family house and lands and income generated by the land—died intestate, the rule of primogeniture applied: the eldest son inherited the family estate. In the absence of children, or of male children, collateral relatives, usually males, in order of seniority, inherited the estate. Primogeniture was the rule applied in cases where a landowner died intestate. But in most cases family estates devolved, not by the rules of intestacy but according to wills or settlements. An outright owner of property did not have to favor his eldest son or other male relations in a will but often did so. The purpose of favoring the eldest son, either by application of the law of primogeniture or by wills or settlements, was to keep family estates intact and free of heavy obligations to support other family members.

Austen shows how the tradition of keeping family property together by bequeathing it to the eldest son, rather than breaking up the property to provide for all, left women in particular at the mercy of the charity of their male relatives. In Sense and Sensibility, Mr. Henry Dashwood is prevented from protecting his widow and daughters because he is bequeathed only a life interest in the family estate. On his death the property goes to his son John and then to John’s son. His daughters are left with just £1000 each.

Settlements of property, often made on the occasion of a marriage, typically gave the husband a life interest in the estate, and the property would be entailed on the eldest son (or other male descendant) (Cecil 44). But the law did not require that settlements follow the rule of primogeniture, and there were exceptions. In Pride and Prejudice, Lady Catherine de Bourgh comments: “‘I see no occasion for entailing estates from the female line.—It was not thought necessary in Sir Lewis de Bourgh’s family’” (185). Lady Catherine is fortunate. In her portrayal of the Bennet family, Austen reveals the hardship imposed by the usual practice of settling the family estate on the eldest male relative. The settlement of the family property prevents Mr. Bennet from providing for his wife and daughters after his death. If a son had been born to the Bennets, the son, rather than Mr. Collins, would have been entitled to the family property on Mr. Bennet’s death. And a son, on attaining the age of majority, could have entered into an agreement with Mr. Bennet that would have cut off the entail and provided for the rest of the family. The son’s motivation for making such an agreement often was his desire to marry. In order to enter into a marriage settlement involving the family property, the father’s consent was required (Neate 18).

Younger sons as well as daughters suffered under the general preference for eldest sons. Their relatively small income and poor prospects made it more difficult for them to marry. In Mansfield Park, Edmund Bertram becomes much more attractive to Mary Crawford when Thomas Bertram, the eldest son, is apparently on his deathbed. And in Pride and Prejudice, Colonel Fitzwilliam, speaking of his relative poverty, says: “‘A younger son, you know, must be inured to self-denial and dependence. . . . Younger sons cannot marry where they like’” (205). But younger sons could at least enter a profession. Edmund Bertram is a clergyman, Colonel Fitzwilliam in the military, and John Knightley a lawyer. Women had no such opportunities.

Educational and employment opportunities for women were extremely limited. Marriage was almost a necessity. In a letter to Fanny Knight, Austen commented that, “Single women have a dreadful propensity for being poor—which is one very strong argument in favour of Matrimony” (13 March 1817). Emma, an heiress, is one of the few women able to say, “‘I have none of the usual inducements of women to marry’” (E 90). Most women were in the position of Charlotte Lucas: “marriage had always been her object it was the only honourable provision for well-educated young women of small fortune, and however uncertain of giving happiness, must be their pleasantest preservative from want” (PP 138).

On marriage, a husband became legally responsible for the support of the wife. If she were forced to leave his house from ill-treatment, the husband would be ordered to provide for her in accordance with his means (Ewers v Hutton). But the cost of obtaining protection from want through marriage was that the wife lost her legal personality. At common law, husband and wife are one person, and that person is the man. On marriage a wife became a “feme covert,” that is, a woman under the protection of her husband. As Blackstone wrote in 1765:

By marriage, the husband and wife are one person in law: that is, the very being or legal existence of the woman is suspended during the marriage, or at least is incorporated and consolidated into that of the husband under whose wing, protection, and cover, she performs every thing and is therefore called in our law-French a feme-covert . . . and her condition during her marriage is called her coverture. (442)

One implication of coverture was that the husband became entitled to his wife’s property and income.

Women of the class that Austen wrote about generally had marriage settlements, under which property was settled on the wife in trust for her separate use. The source of the money settled on the wife might be the wife herself, her family, the husband, or the husband’s family. A certain amount would be specified as her “pin-money” during the marriage. Pin-money was for the dress and the pocket-money of the wife. As well, marriage settlements often provided that a wife would give up her dower rights, a life interest in one-third of all land owned by the husband during the marriage, and receive instead a jointure, a specified sum for her separate use that would be her support if she survived her husband (see generally Howard v Digby).

Pre-marital sex was a risky activity for women in Regency England. The reputation of women, though not of men, was lost among respectable society if their sexual activity outside of marriage became known. Yet some women, tempted by love or lust, or in hopes of marriage, took the chance. Austen brings home the precarious position of women who engaged in pre-marital sex in her portrayals of unmarried cohabitation. Lydia Bennet lives with George Wickham, Penelope Clay with William Elliot, and Maria Rushworth with Henry Crawford. Only Lydia triumphs by marrying her lover and only after Wickham is “‘worked on’” and bribed by Mr. Darcy (PP 306). Mrs. Clay remains hopeful at the end of Persuasion that her lover will be “wheedled and caressed” into marriage (273). But the conclusion of Maria’s elopement is dismal indeed:

She hoped to marry him, and they continued together till she was obliged to be convinced that such hope was vain, and till the disappointment and wretchedness arising from the conviction, rendered her temper so bad, and her feelings for him so like hatred, as to make them for a while each other’s punishment, and then induce a voluntary separation. (MP 536)

Maria is further punished by having to live out her days with Mrs. Norris as her sole companion.

Today, not only has unmarried cohabitation been de-stigmatized, but also many of the rights and obligations of marriage have been extended to those who cohabit outside of marriage, at least in many Western countries (Bailey 35). In Austen’s day, however, Maria would have had no claim against Henry Crawford for support or anything else. Austen shows that she has to rely on her father to be “secured in every comfort” (MP 538).

Sexual encounters, whether as part of long-term relationships or more casual encounters, created the risk of pregnancy for women. John Willoughby’s tryst with Eliza Williams not only results in pregnancy but leaves Eliza ruined: “‘He had left the girl whose youth and innocence he had seduced, in a situation of the utmost distress, with no creditable home, no help, no friends, ignorant of his address!’” (SS 237). Even if she were able to trace Willoughby, Eliza would have no direct legal claim against him but would have to rely on his generosity to obtain any assistance from him for herself or her child. But Willoughby could be forced to support the child by the public authorities.

Children born outside of marriage were, in legal terms, “bastards.” Although we are told that “Harriet Smith was the natural daughter of somebody” (E 22), under the law a bastard was actually nullius filius, the child of nobody (Strangeways v Robinson 428). Those who were destitute were supported by the parish in accordance with the Poor Laws. But under these same laws, the overseers of the parish could obtain court orders against the father (if he could be identified and found) and the mother to support the child or face imprisonment. The payments made by the parents were to indemnify the parish against the costs of supporting the bastard child, but in practice they were often given to the mother. There were concerns during Austen’s day that a “woman of immoral habits could collect a number of such payments from various men in respect of a train of bastards, until she became a local heiress and could make an advantageous match” (Henriques 105). There were also concerns that unscrupulous women were using the threat of the Poor Law to coerce men into payments or marriage. If the father was too poor to pay for the support of the bastard, the parish had to bear the obligation. If the father lived in a different parish, the overseers might coerce the couple into marriage, motivated by a wish to move the obligation of supporting the bastard and any subsequent legitimate children from their own ratepayers to those of the father’s parish.

The Poor Laws had no application to bastards such as Harriet Smith who were privately supported. Emma says of Harriet that “‘[h]er allowance is very liberal nothing has ever been grudged for her improvement or comfort’” (66). Willoughby, the father of Eliza Williams’s child, is not so generous. But for her rescue from distress by Colonel Brandon, Eliza might have been forced to turn to the parish for support of her child. If that were the case, and if she named Willoughby as the father, the parish could have used the Poor Law to force him to provide support for the child.

Marriages within the prohibited degrees of consanguinity (blood relation) were void for incest. Although first cousin marriage is today banned by many states and by the canon law of the Catholic Church (Ottenheimer 325 Code of Canon Law, art 1091), first cousin marriage has been permitted in England for hundreds of years, since the rule of Henry VIII and his break from Rome. The list of relations that one could not marry was laid down in the Marriage Act of 1540 and remained in place during the time of Austen. Under this law, cousins, even first cousins, were not prohibited from marrying (indeed, King George IV and Queen Caroline were first cousins). The possibility of a marriage is a consideration for Sir Thomas Bertram when he ponders the wisdom of undertaking the care of his niece Fanny Price: “He thought of his own four children—of his two sons—of cousins in love, &c.” (MP 6). In the end, Sir Thomas is well satisfied to have Fanny Price as a daughter-in-law. It is not a great match that would unite two splendid fortunes, as is that planned by Lady Catherine De Bourgh for her daughter and nephew. But Fanny brings a clear-eyed sense of right and wrong to the family, a much-valued quality after the moral bankruptcy of the glittering strangers, Henry and Mary Crawford, and of Sir Thomas’s own daughters has been exposed.

Marriages between brothers and sisters of course were prohibited by the Marriage Act. Brothers- and sisters-in-law were covered by the same prohibition: a man could not marry his deceased wife’s sister, and a woman could not marry her deceased husband’s brother. Such marriages were within the prohibited degrees of affinity (relation by marriage) and voidable. The distinction between void and voidable marriages was important. Void marriages were never good, and any children born to parties in a void marriage were bastards. Voidable marriages, on the other hand, were valid subsisting marriages unless and until the marriage was annulled. If a voidable marriage were annulled, any children born to the couple would then become bastards and unable to inherit as legitimate heirs. A voidable marriage could not be impugned after the death of one of the spouses (Elliott v Gurr 19). Therefore, a greedy relative hoping to grab an inheritance could not attack the marriage after the death of one or both spouses with the hope of elbowing out the surviving spouse or children. But while the spouses lived, their marriage could be annulled, and their children would then be bastards. In order to address the uncertain status of children born to parties in a voidable marriage, the Marriage Act of 1835 validated marriages within the prohibited degrees of affinity that had taken place previous to 1835 and had not been annulled, but it deemed any such marriages that took place after passage of the Act to be void.

The 1835 Marriage Act would have applied retroactively to validate the voidable marriage of Austen’s brother Charles with his deceased wife’s sister in 1820. But the May 1847 marriage of Austen’s niece Louisa Knight to Lord George Hill, the husband of Louisa’s deceased sister Cassandra, would have been void because it took place after 1835. In an attempt to avoid this result, Knight and Hill went to Denmark to be married (Hillan 132). Other couples adopted this same strategy, leading to a public inquiry into “the state and operation of the law of marriage, as related to the prohibited degrees of affinity, and to marriages solemnized abroad or in the British colonies,” which included an examination of the marriage of Louisa Knight and Lord George Hill in November 1847 (Great Britain, Commission 26-28). In 1861, the House of Lords handed down a landmark ruling on the validity of marriages within the prohibited degrees affinity that were celebrated abroad (Brook v Brook). The case before the House of Lords involved the 1850 marriage of William Brook and his deceased wife’s sister Emily Armitage. The couple lived in England, but, like Knight and Hill, had traveled to Denmark to marry in order to evade British marriage law. The House of Lords ruled that the Marriage Act of 1835 applied to all British subjects, even those temporarily abroad to celebrate their marriage. Therefore, the marriage of Brook and Armitage was void (as, presumably, was that of Knight and Hill). Heated debates regarding marriage with a deceased wife’s sister continued in Parliament until 1907, when a statute was finally passed allowing such marriages to take place (Anderson 84).

At any rate, a marriage with a deceased wife’s sister or a deceased husband’s brother was voidable in Jane Austen’s time. If John Knightley were to be widowed, he could not enter into a valid marriage with Emma, who is in law his sister. Nor could George Knightley validly marry Isabella, were she to survive her husband. But though Emma and Mr. Knightley have a common sister, Isabella, and a common brother, John Knightley, they are not themselves brother and sister. Emma says to Mr. Knightley, “‘You have shown that you can dance, and you know we are not really so much brother and sister as to make it at all improper’” (E 358). They are in a sense kin, but not legally brother and sister and not within the prohibited degrees. We understand from Emma’s words that she has mistakenly cast Mr. Knightley in the role of brother. This error accounts for her slowness in recognizing him as a lover. Mr. Knightley’s muscular response, “‘Brother and sister! no, indeed’” (E 358), is thrilling because it signals that he is under no similar mistake and quite ready to step forward as dancing partner and lover. Of course, a country-dance is “‘an emblem of marriage’” (NA 74).

Clandestine and underage marriage

Prior to the enactment in 1753 of An Act for the Better Preventing of Clandestine Marriage, commonly known as “Lord Hardwicke’s Act,” couples could marry away from public scrutiny if they could find an ordained clergyman to perform the service. Because many clergymen were willing to conduct private marriages for a fee, clandestine marriages and irregular marriages (bigamous, incestuous, or involving minors) were a problem (Outhwaite 51-54 Stone, Uncertain 25-34). Bigamous and incestuous marriages were invalid but caused tremendous harm to women in particular. A woman who entered into such a sham marriage might surrender her body and property to her apparent husband and then be left unmarried and compromised, perhaps even pregnant with a bastard child. Marriages involving minors were valid, provided the parties had reached the common law age of consent for marriage, which was just fourteen for boys and twelve for girls (Priestly v Hughes 909). The problem with such marriages was that they took place over the often well-founded objections of the family. Legislators sought to prevent all such problematic marriages by imposing rules against private ceremonies.

Lord Hardwicke’s Act provided that marriages must take place in a church after the publication of banns (a notice read out on three successive Sundays in the parish church, announcing an intended marriage and giving the opportunity for objections) or after the parties had obtained a special license. The Act also provided that parties under the age of twenty-one (the age of majority) who were married by special license needed parental consent in order for the marriage to be valid.

Lord Hardwicke’s Act may be kept in mind when considering George Wickham’s planned elopement with Georgiana Darcy. Georgiana was then fifteen years old, a minor but past the common law age of consent, so a valid marriage would have been possible, and a simple matter if Georgiana’s guardians, Colonel Fitzwilliam and Fitzwilliam Darcy, had given their consent to the match. In the absence of such consent, there were two possible ways of proceeding. The first would be for the couple to take up residency in a new parish, where interfering relations could not find them, and have the banns read on three successive Sundays in the absence of objecting guardians. The requirements of Lord Hardwicke’s Act would then be satisfied, and the marriage could have taken place.

The second approach would be to leave the jurisdiction of England and marry in a place where Lord Hardwicke’s Act was not applicable. The Act’s requirements were considered formalities and therefore applicable only in England. Because couples could evade the formal rules by marrying outside of England, many went to Gretna Green in Scotland, just across the English border for this purpose. Although Wickham’s scheme was thwarted when Georgiana confessed the elopement plans to her brother, the danger to Georgiana shows the inadequacy of Lord Hardwicke’s Act to protect against clandestine marriage. Heiresses, such as Georgiana, could still be seduced away from their families and married by fortune-hunters.

Austen also shows how the continuing possibility of clandestine marriage permitted unscrupulous men to seduce young women, even when the men had no intention to carry through with the promised wedding. When Wickham later runs off with Lydia Bennet, who is just sixteen, the initial thought that the couple has eloped to Scotland soon gives way to the realities of Lydia’s precarious position. Jane Bennet writes to her sister Elizabeth: “‘Imprudent as a marriage between Mr. Wickham and our poor Lydia would be, we are now anxious to be assured it has taken place, for there is but too much reason to fear they are not gone to Scotland’” (302). Mr. Gardiner optimistically supposes that “‘it might strike them that they could be more economically, though less expeditiously, married in London, than in Scotland’” (312). This suggestion is a reference to the possibility of the couple’s taking up residency in London and having the banns read on three successive Sundays in their new parish church. It certainly was slower than going to Gretna Green, but, as Mr. Gardiner suggests, perhaps a cheaper method of marrying a minor without parental consent. To the relief of Lydia’s family, the couple does finally marry in London. Only Mr. Darcy’s intervention saves Lydia from being seduced with the promise of marriage and then abandoned.

Both Mr. Rushworth in Mansfield Park and Mr. Brandon in Sense and Sensibility divorce their wives for adultery. It would not have been an easy matter for either gentleman, despite the assertion that “Mr. Rushworth had no difficulty in procuring a divorce” (537). Judicial divorce that would allow the parties to remarry was not available in England until 1857, when the first Matrimonial Causes Act was passed. Prior to 1857, the process was much more difficult and costly. In order to get a divorce that would allow the parties to remarry, it was necessary that Parliament pass a special bill providing for the “relief” of the petitioner. Before seeking such relief, Rushworth and Brandon would have to pursue the remedies available in the courts.

Both Rushworth and Brandon would have sought relief from the Ecclesiastical Court, which administered canon law concerning marital breakdown and annulment (Stone, Road to Divorce 16). Their marriages could not be annulled unless there were some defect or impediment, such as incest, existing at the time of the marriage. In the absence of any ground for annulment, their only remedy at the Ecclesiastical Court would have been a separation from bed and board (known as a divorce a menso et thoro), which could be granted on proof of adultery.

Even if there were evidence of adultery, the defences of connivance, collusion, and condonation were available to a wife in any proceeding before the Ecclesiastical Court for a legal separation on the basis of the wife’s adultery (Dounn v Dounn). Connivance required the wife to show that the husband had actively encouraged the adultery of his wife. An example of conduct that might ground a claim of connivance was that of Sir Richard Worsley, who notoriously supported his wife’s lover while the lover viewed the naked Lady Worsley (Kaplan 209-10). Collusion was any agreement to fabricate or suppress evidence or to deceive the court. Condonation was forgiveness of the adultery. These defences reflected the prevailing norm that parties had a duty to live together as man and wife unless a matrimonial offence were proven and that they should not be permitted to separate simply because they no longer wished to be together.

In addition to obtaining a legal separation, a husband seeking a Parliamentary divorce on the ground of adultery generally was required first to obtain a judgment for “criminal conversation” (adultery) against his wife’s paramour (the wife was not a party to the proceeding). Criminal conversation was a private action based on a civil wrong, and the remedy was an award of damages to the aggrieved husband. Despite the terminology, adultery was not a crime for which the state would prosecute offenders. It was a matrimonial offence in the Ecclesiastical Court that would ground a claim for separation, and it was a civil wrong for which a husband could claim damages, but in Austen’s day the state would not prosecute a party for adultery.

Adultery had been made a crime punishable by death for both guilty parties in the year 1650 by the Act for Suppressing the Detestable Sins of Incest, Adultery and Fornication. But this statute was repealed at the Restoration and never replaced, a matter of regret to at least one Victorian constitutional scholar who lamented the lack of criminal sanction for adultery, or at least adultery by a wife:

Of the various crimes against civilised society, this seems one of the greatest. It poisons domestic felicity, it alienates parents from their children, and introduces all the train of evils attending want of parental affection, and of proper culture in youth. The man whose wife is seduced from him sustains an infinitely greater injury than he could have done from any loss of property since the children for whom he was daily toiling, anxiously accumulating, and exposing himself to privations, are now covered with their mother’s shame, and must enter the world under reproach, while the tender father can no longer regard them with confidence as his own offspring. (Brodie 427)

As is evident from this excerpt, efforts to criminalize the adultery of wives were fueled by male anxiety as to the true paternity of their children.

In Austen’s day, the limited sanctions for adultery were a matter of regret for some Parliamentarians, to whom petitions for bills of divorcement were presented. In response to the growing number of petitions for divorce over the course of the eighteenth century, there were calls for reform. On 2 April 1800, Lord Auckland introduced in the House of Lords a bill that would provide the following: “It shall not be lawful for the person, on account of whose adultery a marriage should be dissolved, to intermarry with the person with whom the adultery shall have been committed” (Great Britain, Parliament 1819, 225). Lord Auckland explained that he did not seek to recriminalize adultery but thought it appropriate to consider whether “for the sake of public morality, that the crime of adultery be subject to some chastisement beyond that of a civil action for pecuniary damages” (Great Britain, Parliament 1819, 226). Perhaps emboldened by the strong denunciations of adulterous wives during the debate, Lord Auckland decided to go further. On 16 May 1800, he introduced a new version of his bill that now included a clause that would “make persons guilty of adultery liable to be punished by fine and imprisonment, as in cases of misdemeanour” (Great Britain, Parliament 1819, 236). Despite generating a substantial amount of support, the bill was never passed. 1

The requirement that a man first obtain a judgment for criminal conversation before petitioning Parliament for the bill of divorcement could be waived if to do so was impracticable. While in the large majority of cases, such a judgment would be obtained, it was not required if the wife’s lover was unknown or deceased (Lardner’s Divorce 812-13).

The damages awarded by juries for criminal conversation were not determined by any formula and could vary widely. One defendant unsuccessfully sought a new trial on the grounds that the £5,000 damages awarded were excessive. In refusing the request for a new trial, the court reasoned that there was no benchmark against which the damages could be measured. One of the judges, Justice Grose, commented:

We have known many of these cases where very large damages have been given, particularly one of £10,000 against a person in the situation of a servant. If anything could have warranted the interference prayed for [i.e., ordering a new trial on the grounds of excessive damages], we may fairly presume it was that, where the damages given were tantamount to imprisonment for life and yet no new trial was granted. (Duberley against Gunning 1230)

The patent inability of the defendant to pay was not a relevant factor when exercising discretion to determine damages.

While damage awards for criminal conversation could be large, there is reason to think that at least some husbands did not enforce the awards. During Parliamentary debates, the Duke of Clarence (later William IV), asserted that a husband who obtained a verdict was considered “not as a very honourable man” if he kept the damages rather than returning them to the defendant (Great Britain, Parliament 1819, 229). Lord Eldon, a judge and later Lord Chancellor, argued that most criminal conversation actions were part of collusive schemes and never intended to result in payments by the wife’s lover to the husband:

nine out of every ten cases of adultery that came to the courts below, or to that bar, were founded in the most infamous collusion, and that, as the law stood, it was a farce and a mockery, most of the cases being settled in some room in the city, . . . and juries were called to give exemplary damages, which damages were never paid, nor expected to be paid by the injured husband. (Great Britain, Parliament 1819, 237)

Lord Eldon disapproved the state of the law under which a husband could obtain the cooperation of his wife’s lover by a collusive arrangement under which the damages for criminal conversation were never collected.

Wives could not bring an action for criminal conversation. The law reflected the deeply-held belief that adultery by husbands should be forgiven but adultery by wives required serious sanction because it “necessarily breaks asunder all family ties, and may introduce into the family circle a spurious offspring” (Great Britain, Parliament 1857, 880). Although wives could obtain a separation from bed and board in the Ecclesiastical Courts on the grounds of adultery (Durant v Durant 748), almost all Parliamentary divorces were granted to husbands. None were granted to wives prior to 1791, and of eighty-eight Parliamentary divorces granted between 1791 and 1820, only one was granted to a wife (James 174). Austen illustrates the devastating impact of divorce on women in her stories of Maria Rushworth and Eliza Brandon. Their husbands may have undergone some trouble and expense to obtain divorces, but they were not exiled from society or left destitute. Nor did the paramours of wives suffer banishment. Henry Crawford did not suffer “the public punishment of disgrace” as did Maria Rushworth, and Austen comments that “the penalty [for adultery] is less equal than could be wished” (MP 542).

In Sense and Sensibility, Colonel Brandon gives a sad account of the fate of his first love, concluding: “‘She left to my care her only child, a little girl, the offspring of her first guilty connection, who was then about three years old’” (SS 236). Because of this clear statement that Eliza Williams was the result of a “‘guilty connection,’” it has been assumed that she was an illegitimate child (Hildebrand Nelson 164). Yet Austen actually does not give us sufficient information to form that conclusion. Indeed the facts we are given better support an assumption that a court would have ruled that Eliza was not a bastard at all but the child of her mother’s husband, Mr. Brandon. There was at the time a strong legal presumption in favor of legitimacy.

The presumption in favor of legitimacy meant that the status of a child born to a married woman could not be impeached without unequivocal proof that the husband was not the father. It had to be shown with irresistible evidence that the husband was impotent, that the husband was divorced from the wife (separation was insufficient), or that the husband was absent from England, or at least did not have access to his wife, when the child was conceived (The King against Luffe Nicolas 27-28). Even if all the parties involved had acknowledged that Eliza Williams’s biological father was her mother’s lover, the law could still regard Eliza as the child of her mother’s husband. If Mr. Brandon had not yet obtained his divorce, was not clearly proven to be impotent, and was in England at the relevant time, Eliza would have been ruled legitimate.

Another common assumption is that Eliza’s surname, Williams, came from her mother (Nelson 164). But it should be noted that, while we are told that Eliza’s mother was also called “Eliza,” we are never given the mother’s surname. Williams could have been the maiden name of the mother. Another possibility is that Williams was the name of the mother’s “‘first guilty connection.’” But whatever the source of Eliza Williams’s surname, the failure to give her the name “Brandon” at birth would by no means have determined the issue of her legitimacy.

Despite the strong presumption in their favor, it is unlikely that many offspring of “‘guilty connections’” would have sought to prove their legitimacy in court. In cases of acknowledged adultery by the mother, there would likely have been an assumption among those without legal training that any attempt to establish legitimacy would be unsuccessful. At best, their chances would have seemed highly uncertain. And the expense of court proceedings would have been prohibitive for those, like Eliza Williams or her mother, who were left impoverished after the indiscretion of the mother.

Along the road to the happy ending of marriage, Austen reveals how marriage laws and settlements limited the life choices of men and women. As well, she shows the hardships imposed on women in particular who engaged in pre-marital sex or adultery. The failure of Lord Hardwicke’s Act to prevent clandestine and underage marriage is brought home by the stories of Georgiana Darcy and Lydia Bennet. There is sometimes said to be a gap between the law in the books and the law in action. Austen shows the law in action—how marriage laws operated in practice and how parties manoeuvred within the legal structures of the time.


1 For further discussion of this bill, see Craig (127-29), where it is referred to as the “Divorce Bill.” Stone uses the term “Anti-Adultery Bill” ( Road to Divorce 335-39).

Works Cited
  • An Act for Suppressing the Detestable Sins of Incest, Adultery and Fornication. 1650, 2 Acts & Ords, Interregnum 387.
  • An Act for the Better Preventing of Clandestine Marriage. 1753 26 Geo 2, c 33.
  • Anderson, Nancy F. “The ‘Marriage with a Deceased Wife’s Sister Bill’ Controversy: Incest Anxiety and the Defense of Family Purity in Victorian England.” Journal of British Studies 21.2 (1982): 67-86.
  • Austen, Jane. The Cambridge Edition of the Works of Jane Austen. Gen. ed. Janet Todd. Cambridge: CUP, 2005-2008.
  • _____. Jane Austen’s Letters. Ed. Deirdre Le Faye. 3rd ed. Oxford: OUP, 1995.
  • Bailey, Martha. “Unmarried Cohabitation in Quebec—Liberté ou Égalité?” International Survey of Family Law. Ed. William Atkin. London: Jordans, 2014. 33-40.
  • Brook v. Brook. 1861. 9 H.L. Cas. 193.
  • Blackstone, William. Commentaries on the Laws of England. Vol. 1. Oxford: Clarendon, 1765.
  • Brodie, George. A Constitutional History of the British Empire: From the Accession of Charles I to the Restoration. Vol. 3. London: Longmans, 1866.
  • Cecil, Evelyn. Primogeniture. London: Murray, 1895.
  • Code of Canon Law. Book 4, Part 1, Title 7, Ch. 3.
  • Craig, Sheryl. “‘So Ended a Marriage.’” Persuasions 36 (2014): 117-35.
  • Dounn v Dounn. 1817. 161 ER 1182.
  • Duberley against Gunning. 1792. 100 ER 1226.
  • Durant v Durant. 1828. 162 ER 734.
  • Elliott v Gurr. 1812. 2 Phillim. Eccl. Rep. (Eng.) 16.
  • Ewers v Hutton. 1819. 170 ER 607 (A).
  • Great Britain. Commission to Inquire into the State and Operation of the Law of Marriage, as Related to the Prohibited Degrees of Affinity, and to Marriages Solemnized Abroad or in the British Colonies. London: Eyre, 1856.
  • Great Britain, Parliament. The Parliamentary History of England. Vol. 35. London: Hansard, 1819.
  • Great Britain, Parliament. The Parliamentary History of England. Vol.167. London: Hansard, 1857.
  • Henriques, U. R. Q. “Bastardy and the New Poor Law.” Past & Present 37 (1967): 103-29.
  • Hildebrand, Enid G. “Jane Austen and the Law.” Persuasions 4 (1982): 34-41.
  • Hillan, Sophia. May, Lou & Cass: Jane Austen’s Nieces in Ireland. Belfast: Blackstaff, 2011.
  • Hodges v Hodges. 1795. 162 ER 1100.
  • Howard v Digby. 1834. 6 ER 1293.
  • Kaplan, Laurie. “The Rushworths of Wimpole Street.” Persuasions 33 (2011): 202-14.
  • Larder’s Divorce (In re). 1839. 7 ER 812 (B).
  • James, Douglas. “Parliamentary Divorce, 1700–1857.” Parliamentary History 31.2 (2012): 169-89.
  • Marriage Act. 1540. 32 Hen 8 c 38.
  • Marriage Act. 1835. 6 Will IV, c 54.
  • Matrimonial Causes Act. 1857, 20 & 21 Vict, c 85.
  • Moorsom v Moorsom. 1792. 162 ER 1090.
  • Neate, Charles. The History and Uses of the Law of Entail and Settlement. London: Ridgway, 1865.
  • Nelson, Bonnie G. “Rethinking Marianne Dashwood’s Very Strong Resemblance to Eliza Brandon.” Persuasions 34 (2012): 164-78.
  • Nicolas, Harris. The Law of Adulterine Bastardy. London: Pickering, 1836.
  • Ottenheimer, Martin. “Lewis Henry Morgan and the Prohibition of Cousin Marriage in the United States.” Journal of Family History 15.1 (1990): 325-34.
  • Outhwaite, R. B. Clandestine Marriage in England, 1500-1850. London: Hambledon, 1995.
  • Priestly v Hughes. 1809. 103 ER 903.
  • Stone, Lawrence. Road to Divorce: England 1530-1987. Oxford: OUP, 1992.
  • _____. Uncertain Unions and Broken Lives. Oxford: OUP, 1995.
  • Strangeways v Robinson. 1812. 128 ER 423.
  • The King against Luffe. 1807. 103 ER 316.
  • Wagner, John A. Voices of Victorian England: Contemporary Accounts of Daily Life. Santa Barbara: ABC-CLIO, 2014.

About JASNA

The Jane Austen Society of North America is dedicated to the enjoyment and appreciation of Jane Austen and her writing. JASNA is a nonprofit organization, staffed by volunteers, whose mission is to foster among the widest number of readers the study, appreciation, and understanding of Jane Austen’s works, her life, and her genius. We have over 5,000 members of all ages and from diverse walks of life. Although most live in the United States or Canada, we also have members in more than a dozen other countries.

©2021 The Jane Austen Society of North America, Inc. All rights reserved.


Issues of Concern

Indications for Mechanical Ventilation

The most common indication for intubation and mechanical ventilation is in cases of acute respiratory failure,਎ither hypoxic or hypercapnic.

Other important indications include a decreased level of consciousness with an inability to protect the airway, respiratory distress that failed non-invasive positive pressure ventilation, cases of massive hemoptysis, severe angioedema, or any case of airway compromise such as airway burns, cardiac arrest, and shock.

Common elective indications for mechanical ventilation are surgical procedures and neuromuscular disorders.

There are no direct contraindications for mechanical ventilation as it is a life-saving measure in a critically ill patient, and all patients should be offered the opportunity to benefit from this if needed.

The only absolute contraindication for mechanical ventilation is if it is against the patient's stated wishes for artificial life-sustaining measures.

The only relative contraindication is if non-invasive ventilation is available and its use is expected to resolve the need for mechanical ventilation. This should be started first as it has fewer complications than mechanical ventilation.

In order to initiate mechanical ventilation, certain measures should be taken. Proper placement of the endotracheal tube must be verified. This may be done by end-tidal capnography or a combination of clinical and radiological findings.

Proper cardiovascular support should be ensured with fluids or vasopressors as indicated on a case by case basis.

Ensure that proper sedation and analgesia are available. The plastic tube in the patient's throat is painful and uncomfortable, and if the patient is restless or fighting the tube or the vent, it will make it much more difficult to control the different ventilation and oxygenation parameters.

After intubating a patient and connecting to the ventilator, it is time to select the mode of ventilation to be used. Several principles need to be grasped in order to do this consistently for the patient's benefit.

As mentioned, compliance is the change in volume divided by the change in pressure. When mechanically ventilating a patient, one can select how the ventilator will deliver the breaths. The ventilator can be set up to either deliver a set amount of volume or a set amount of pressure, and it is up to the clinician to decide which would be more beneficial for the patient. When selecting what the ventilator will deliver, you are selecting which will be the dependent and which will be the independent variable in the lung compliance equation.

If we select to start the patient on volume-controlled ventilation, the ventilator will always deliver the same amount of volume (independent variable), and the generated pressure will be dependent on the compliance. If compliance is poor, the pressure will be high, and barotrauma could ensue.

If on the other hand, we decide to start the patient on pressure-controlled ventilation, the ventilator will always deliver the same pressure during the respiratory cycle. However, the tidal volume will depend on lung compliance, and in cases where compliance frequently changes (like in asthma) this will generate unreliable tidal volumes and may cause hypercapnia or hyperventilation.

After selecting how the breath is delivered (by pressure or volume) the clinician has to decide which mode of ventilation to use. This means selecting if the ventilator will assist all the patient’s breaths, some patient’s breaths, or none of them and also selecting if the ventilator will deliver breaths even if the patient is not breathing on its own.

Other parameters that should be considered are how fast the breath is delivered (flow), what will be the waveform of that flow (decelerating waveform mimics physiological breaths and is more comfortable for the patient, while square waveforms in which the flow is given at full speed during all inhalation, are more uncomfortable for the patient but deliver quicker inspiratory times), and at what rate will breaths be delivered. All these parameters should be adjusted to achieve patient comfort, desired blood gasses, and prevent air trapping.

There are many different modes of ventilation that vary minimally between each other. In this review, we will focus on the most common modes of ventilation and their clinical use. The mode of ventilation includes assist control (AC), pressure support (PS), synchronized intermittent mandatory ventilation (SIMV), and airway pressure release ventilation (APRV).

Assist Control Ventilation (AC)

Assist control is when the ventilator will assist the patient by delivering support for every breath the patient takes (that is the assist part), and the ventilator will have control over the respiratory rate if it goes below the set rate (control part). In assist control, if the rate is set at 12 and the patient breathes at 18, the ventilator will assist with the 18 breaths, but if the rate drops to 8, the ventilator will take over control of the respiratory rate and deliver 12 breaths in a minute.

In assist control ventilation, the breath can be delivered by either giving volume or giving pressure. This is termed volume-assist control or pressure-assist control ventilation. In order to maintain simplicity, and understanding that given that ventilation is commonly a major problem than pressure and that volume control is used overwhelmingly more commonly than pressure control, the focus for the remainder of this review will use the term "volume control" interchangeably when discussing assist control.

Assist control (volume control) is the mode of choice used in the majority of intensive care units throughout the United States because it is easy to use. Four settings can be easily adjusted in the ventilator (respiratory rate, tidal volume, FiO2, and PEEP). The volume delivered by the ventilator in each breath in assist control will always be the same, regardless of the breath being initiated by the patient or the ventilator, and regardless of compliance, peak, or plateau pressures in the lungs.

Each breath can be time-triggered (if the patient's respiratory rate is below the set ventilator rate, the machine will deliver breaths at a set interval of time) or patient-triggered if the patient initiates a breath on its own. This makes assist control a very comfortable mode for the patient as each of his or her efforts will be supplemented by the ventilator.

After making changes on the vent or after starting a patient on mechanical ventilation, careful consideration of checking arterial blood gases should be made and the oxygen saturation on the monitor should be followed to determine if further changes should be made to the ventilator.

The advantages of AC mode are increased comfort, easy corrections for respiratory acidosis/alkalosis, and low work breathing for the patient. Some disadvantages include that being a volume-cycled mode, pressures cannot be directly controlled which may cause barotrauma, the patient can develop hyperventilation with breath stacking, auto-PEEP, and respiratory alkalosis.

For a full description of Assist Control, please review the article titled “Ventilation, Assist Control.”[6]

Synchronized Intermittent Mandatory Ventilation (SIMV)

SIMV is another frequently used mode of ventilation, although its use had been falling out of favor given its less reliable tidal volumes and failure to show better outcomes when compared to AC.

"Synchronized" means that the ventilator will adjust the delivery of its breaths with the patient’s efforts. "Intermittent"  means that not all breaths are necessarily supported, and "mandatory ventilation" means that, as with AC,ਊ set rate is selected and the ventilator will deliver these mandatory breaths each minute regardless of the patient’s respiratory efforts. The mandatory breaths can be triggered by the patient or by time if the patient’s RR is slower than the ventilator RR (as with AC). The difference from AC is that in SIMV the ventilator only will deliver the breaths that the rate is set up to deliver, any breath taken by the patient above this rate will not receive a full tidal volume or pressure support. This means that for each breath the patient takes above the set RR, the tidal volume pulled by the patient will depend solely on lung compliance and patient effort. This has been proposed as a method of “training” the diaphragm in order to maintain the muscular tone and wean off patients from the ventilator faster. Nonetheless, multiple studies have failed to show any advantages to SIMV. Furthermore, SIMV generates higher work of breathing than AC, which negatively impacts outcomes as well as generates respiratory fatigue. A general rule to go by is that the patient will be liberated from the ventilator when he or she is ready, and no specific mode of ventilation will make this faster. In the meantime, it is better to keep the patient as comfortable as possible and SIMV may not be the best mode to achieve this.

Pressure Support Ventilation (PSV)

PSV is a ventilator mode that relies completely on patient-triggered breaths. As the name implies it is a pressure-driven mode of ventilation. In this setting all breaths are patient-triggered as the ventilator has no backup rate, so each breath has to be started by the patient. In this mode, the ventilator will cycle between two different pressures (PEEP and pressure support). PEEP will be the remaining pressure at the end of exhalation, and pressure support is the pressure above the PEEP that the ventilator will administer during each breath for support of ventilation. This means that if a patient is set up in PSV 10/5, the patient will receive 5 cm H2O of PEEP, and during inhalation, he will receive 15 cm H2O of support (10 PS above PEEP).

Because there is no backup rate, this mode is not for use in patients with decreased consciousness, shock, or cardiac arrest. The tidal volumes will depend solely on the patient’s effort and lung compliance.

PSV often is used for ventilator weaning as it only augments patients breathing efforts but does not deliver a set tidal volume or respiratory rate.

The biggest drawback of PSV is its unreliable tidal volumes that may generate CO2 retention and acidosis as well as the higher work of breathing which can lead to respiratory fatigue.

To address this concern, a new algorithm for PSV was created called volume support ventilation (VSV). VSV is a similar mode to PSV, but in this mode, the tidal volume is used as feedback control, as the pressure support given to the patient will be constantly adjusted to the tidal volume. In this setting, if the tidal volume is decreasing, the ventilator will increase the pressure support to decrease the tidal volume and if the tidal volume increases the pressure support will decrease in order to keep the tidal volume close to the desired minute ventilation. There is some਎vidence suggesting that the use of VSV may decrease assisted ventilation time, total weaning time, and total T-piece time as well as a decreased need for sedation.

Airway Pressure Release Ventilation (APRV)

As the name suggests, in APRV mode the ventilator will deliver a constant high airway pressure that will deliver oxygenation, and ventilation will be served by releasing that pressure.

This mode has recently gained popularity as an alternative for difficult-to-oxygenate patients with ARDS in whom other modes of ventilation fail to reach the set targets. APRV has been described as a continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) with an intermittent release phase. What this means is that the ventilator applies a continuous high pressure (P high) for a set amount of time (T high) and then releases that pressure, usually going back to zero (P low) for a much shorter period of time (T low).

The idea behind this is that during T high (which covers 80% to 95% of the cycle), there is constant alveolar recruitment, which improves oxygenation as the time maintained on high pressure is much longer than in other types of ventilation (open lung strategy). This reduces the repetitive inflation and deflation of the lungs that happens with other ventilator modes, preventing ventilator-induced lung injury. During this time (T high) the patient is free to breathe spontaneously (which makes it comfortable) but he will be pulling low tidal volumes as exhaling against such pressure is harder. Then, when T high is reached, the pressure in the ventilator will go down to P low (usually zero). This allows for air to be rushed out of the airways allowing for passive exhalation until T low is reached and the vent delivers another breath. To prevent airway collapse during this time the T low is set short, usually around 0.4-0.8 seconds. What happens here is that when the ventilator pressure goes to zero, the elastic recoil of the lungs pushes air out, but the time is not enough for all the air to leave the lungs, so the alveolar and airway pressure does not reach zero and there is no airway collapse.  This time is usually set up so that T low ends when the exhalation flow drops to 50% of the initial flow.

Minute ventilation, then, will depend on T low and the patient’s tidal volumes during T high.


For over 100 years Booklist magazine has helped tens of thousands of librarians as a book review source, and readers’ advisory, collection development, and professional development resource. Booklist magazine, and its quarterly supplement Book Links, deliver over 8,000+ recommended-only reviews of books, audiobooks, and reference sources each year, spanning every age and genre.

Booklist Online includes a growing archive from more than 25 years of reviews, as well as a wealth of free content offering the latest news and views on books and media. Now you can read the digital editions of Booklist - online or through a mobile device.

What's happening with books? Visit The Booklist Reader, the blog for librarians and other book lovers, to find out.


Africa Access

Africa Access, a 501 c (3) organization was founded in 1989 to help schools, public libraries, and parents improve the quality of their K-12 collections on Africa. Africa Access Review, Read Africa and Children’s Africana Book Awards (CABA) have been effective initiatives in our efforts to inform the public about quality K-12 books on Africa.

To access the comprehensive Africa Access Review database click: Africa Access Review Database

For a Word Press version of recent reviews enter the title of the book into the SEARCH BOX on this page. You are invited to: Add your comments and ratings for a book.

Tricia Elam Walker Aya Khalil Nelda LaTeef Victoria Jamieson and Omar Mohamed
Adrienne Wright Lupita Nyong’o Kwame Mbalia Elizabeth Zunon Tochi Onyebuchi
Luke Molver & Mason O’Conner Luke Molver & Mason O’Conner Tomi Adeyeme Somaiya Daud Atinuke Kathryn Erskine Portia Dery
Nansybuga Isdahl Arushi Raina Kwame Alexander & Mary Rand Hess Emily Williamson Nnedi Okorafor
Franck Franck PrévotPrévot Desmond Tutu Elizabeth Wein Keely Hutton Evan Turk
Tina Athaide Abena Eyeson Natalie C. Anderson. J.L Powers

The Best Books of 2020

The Best Books of 2020
FICTION AND NONFICTION

In a year replete with notable novels, revelatory works of history and eye-opening examinations of the world around us, 10 stood out from the crowd. The editors of the Journal’s books pages pick the year’s most distinguished fiction and nonfiction.

The Best Books of 2020
MYSTERIES
By Tom Nolan

Our mysteries columnist tracks down the best crime fiction of the year, including a thriller from World War II Paris, a rural cop’s hunt for a woodland killer, the return of Louise Penny’s Quebecois police inspector and more.

The Best Books of 2020
CHILDREN’S BOOKS
By Meghan Cox Gurdon

Mrs. Gurdon’s year in reviewing reveals treasures for readers of nearly any age: picture books that span the globe, gripping true stories of human resilience, and tales of fantasy from voices familiar and new.

The Best Books of 2020
POLITICS
By Barton Swaim

Christopher Caldwell diagnoses a government-addicted culture, Michael Lind takes on technocratic elites and Paul Matzko heralds the power of populist radio. Columnist Barton Swaim makes his pick of books that will outlast 2020’s political roller coaster.

The Best Books of 2020
SCIENCE FICTION
By Tom Shippey

A new sequel returns fans to the world of “The Witches of Karres,” Christina Henry takes readers on a journey to a haunted town and Christopher Paolini leaves “Eragon” for outer space—plus more of 2020’s best from our sci-fi reviewer’s bookshelf.


Watch the video: Αγαπημένα Παιδικά Βιβλία u0026 Διαγωνισμός!